JAZZPROFILES lives in the music 1,765 Jazz Artists fully Profiled!
This Day in Jazz — September 16, 1950

Coltrane Called In Sick, and the Substitute May Not Be Who the Label Said He Was

Portrait of trumpeter Dizzy Gillespie in New York, around May 1947

On September 16, 1950, Dizzy Gillespie took a sextet into a New York studio for Prestige — a label not yet two years old, the session logged at matrix numbers 108 through 111 — with Jimmy Heath on alto, Milt Jackson doubling vibes and piano, Percy Heath on bass and Joe Harris on drums. The tenor chair went to Jimmy Oliver, a Philadelphian who spent his career declining the road; by his own account, his family and a clear-eyed fear of the drugs killing his contemporaries kept him home. The standard account has him deputising for an ill John Coltrane, then in Gillespie’s band and mid-way through his own switch from alto to tenor. Four titles were cut. “She’s Gone Again” carries Oliver’s solo — one of the very few recordings he is known to have made, and one some discographers still refuse to credit him with, filing “Jimmy Oliver” as a pseudonym for Seldon Powell.

Dizzy Gillespie in New York, around May 1947 — three years before the Prestige sextet date whose tenor chair is still argued over. No freely licensed photograph of Jimmy Oliver is known to exist. (Photo: William P. Gottlieb, Public Domain — Gottlieb donated the rights to his 1938–1948 jazz photographs to the public — via the Library of Congress and Wikimedia Commons)

Sources: Dizzy Gillespie Discography — Jazz Discography Project (September 16, 1950 sextet session: Jimmy Oliver on tenor, full personnel, four titles) , Prestige Records Discography: 1950 — Jazz Discography Project (matrix 108–111; “She’s Gone Again” issued on Prestige 736) , Jimmy Oliver (musician) — Wikipedia (Philadelphia career; sitting in for an ill Coltrane on September 16, 1950; the solo on “She’s Gone Again”) , “Jimmy Oliver has passed away” — organissimo forums (Philadelphia Inquirer obituary; discographer Michael Fitzgerald on sources listing “Jimmy Oliver” as a pseudonym for Seldon Powell) , Jimmy Oliver — Philadelphia Jazz (phillyjazz.us) (his bands, the Zanzibar Café, and his decision to stay in Philadelphia) , John Coltrane Discography, session index — Jazz Discography Project (no Coltrane session on September 16, 1950; alto with the Gillespie sextet in mid-1950, tenor by the January 1951 Birdland broadcasts)

← See every This Day in Jazz